Appraisal Right of a Dissenting Stockholder in the Philippines: When and How to Use It


The appraisal right lets a stockholder who votes against certain major corporate acts demand payment of the fair value of the shares. It applies in four instances, such as a merger or the sale of all or substantially all corporate assets.
The stockholder must make a written demand on the corporation within 30 days from the date the vote was taken. Failure to make the demand within that period is deemed a waiver of the right (Republic Act No. 11232, Sections 80 and 81).
Read the full text: Republic Act No. 11232 (Revised Corporation Code)
What is the appraisal right of a stockholder?
It is the right of a stockholder to dissent from certain corporate acts and to demand payment of the fair value of the shares. Title X of the Revised Corporation Code, Sections 80 to 85, governs it.
When may a stockholder use the appraisal right?
Section 80 lists four instances:
An amendment to the articles of incorporation that changes or restricts the rights of any stockholder or class of shares, authorizes preferences superior to those of outstanding shares of any class, or extends or shortens the term of corporate existence.
A sale, lease, exchange, transfer, mortgage, pledge or other disposition of all or substantially all of the corporate property and assets.
A merger or consolidation.
An investment of corporate funds for any purpose other than the primary purpose of the corporation.
Other sections of the Code repeat the right for the act they cover, such as Section 36 on the extension of the corporate term, Section 39 on the sale of assets, Section 41 on investments and Section 76 on mergers. These acts need the vote of the stockholders. See our guides on board and stockholders' meetings and on how to amend the articles of incorporation.
How is the appraisal right exercised?
Sections 81 and 85 set the steps:
Vote against the proposed corporate action.
Make a written demand on the corporation for the payment of the fair value of the shares, within 30 days from the date the vote was taken. Failure to make the demand within this period is deemed a waiver of the appraisal right.
Within 10 days after demanding payment, submit the certificates of stock to the corporation for notation that the shares are dissenting shares. Failure to do so, at the option of the corporation, terminates the rights under Title X.
If the corporate action is implemented, surrender the certificates and receive payment of the fair value.
How is the fair value of the shares set?
The fair value is the value of the shares as of the day before the vote was taken. It excludes any appreciation or depreciation in anticipation of the corporate action.
The stockholder and the corporation may agree on the amount. If they cannot agree within 60 days from the approval of the corporate action by the stockholders, three disinterested persons determine and appraise it. The stockholder names one, the corporation names another, and the two choose the third.
The findings of the majority of the appraisers are final. The corporation must pay their award within 30 days after the award is made. Upon payment, the stockholder must transfer the shares to the corporation.
Can the corporation pay if it has no unrestricted retained earnings?
No.
Section 81 states that no payment may be made to a dissenting stockholder unless the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings in its books to cover the payment.
The Code protects the stockholder in that case. If the dissenting stockholder is not paid within 30 days after the award, the voting and dividend rights are immediately restored (Section 82).
What happens to the stockholder's rights after the demand?
From the time of the demand, all rights accruing to the shares are suspended, including voting and dividend rights. The suspension lasts until the corporate action is abandoned or the corporation purchases the shares. The right to receive payment of the fair value is not suspended.
When does the right to be paid end?
A demand for payment may not be withdrawn unless the corporation consents. Under Section 83, the right to be paid the fair value ceases in these cases:
the demand is withdrawn with the consent of the corporation;
the corporation abandons or rescinds the proposed corporate action;
the SEC disapproves the action, where its approval is necessary; or
the SEC determines that the stockholder is not entitled to the appraisal right.
The stockholder's status is then restored, and all dividend distributions that would have accrued on the shares are paid to the stockholder.
A transfer of the shares also ends the right. If shares that bear the notation are transferred, the transferor's rights as a dissenting stockholder cease, and the transferee has the rights of a regular stockholder (Section 85). See our guide on how to transfer shares of stock.
Who pays for the appraisal?
The corporation bears the costs and expenses of appraisal. The stockholder bears them if the fair value found by the appraisers is approximately the same as the price that the corporation offered to pay (Section 84).
Frequently asked questions
Can a stockholder who did not vote against the act use the appraisal right?
Section 81 gives the right to "the dissenting stockholder who votes against a proposed corporate action." In practice, a stockholder who wants to keep the right should make sure that the vote against the action is recorded.
Is the 30-day period counted from notice of the result?
No.
Section 81 counts the 30 days from the date on which the vote was taken.
Does the appraisal right apply to any act that a stockholder dislikes?
No.
It applies only in the instances stated in the Code. Other disputes call for other remedies, such as a derivative suit or another intra-corporate dispute.
Is there a wider right in a close corporation?
Yes.
Under Section 104, a stockholder of a close corporation may, for any reason, compel the corporation to purchase the shares at fair value, which must not be less than the par or issued value, when the corporation has sufficient assets in its books to cover its debts and liabilities exclusive of capital stock.
Sources
Republic Act No. 11232 (Revised Corporation Code), Sections 80 to 85
Republic Act No. 11232 (Revised Corporation Code), Sections 36, 39, 41, 76 and 104
Need help with SEC or corporate compliance?
We handle SEC registration and reportorial filings, corporate governance, contracts and transactions for Philippine corporations and foreign investors. See our corporate services.
You can also email info@aureadalaw.com or call (02) 8812-9990.
Related guides
This article is general information as of its publication date, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. For advice on your situation, consult a lawyer.



Comments