top of page

Derivative Suit in the Philippines: Requirements Before a Stockholder Can Sue for the Corporation

Writer: Atty. Yasser R. Aureada, CPA
Atty. Yasser R. Aureada, CPA
19 hours ago
5 min read

A derivative suit is a case filed by a stockholder in the name of the corporation, to enforce a right that belongs to the corporation. It is allowed only if the requisites in Rule 8, Section 1 of the Interim Rules of Procedure for Intra-Corporate Controversies are met.


In Villamor, Jr. v. Umale, G.R. Nos. 172843 and 172881, September 24, 2014, the Supreme Court listed five requisites and ruled that a case which does not meet them is not a derivative suit.



What is a derivative suit?


The Supreme Court described a derivative suit as an action filed by stockholders to enforce a corporate action. It is an exception to the general rule that the corporation's power to sue is exercised only by the board of directors or trustees.


A stockholder may sue on behalf of the corporation when the directors or officers refuse to sue to protect the corporation's rights, or when they are the ones to be sued and they control the corporation. The Court added that it is allowed when the directors or officers are guilty of breach of trust, and not of mere error of judgment.


In a derivative suit, the real party in interest is the corporation. The stockholder who sues is only a nominal party. A derivative suit is one kind of intra-corporate dispute.


What are the requirements of a derivative suit?


Rule 8, Section 1 of the Interim Rules allows a stockholder or member to bring an action in the name of a corporation or association, provided that:


  1. He was a stockholder or member at the time the acts or transactions complained of occurred, and at the time the action was filed.


  2. He exerted all reasonable efforts to exhaust all remedies available under the articles of incorporation, by-laws, laws or rules governing the corporation to obtain the relief he desires, and he alleges these efforts with particularity in the complaint.


  3. No appraisal rights are available for the act or acts complained of.


  4. The suit is not a nuisance or harassment suit.


The Supreme Court counted a fifth requisite, implied in the first paragraph of the rule: the action must be brought in the name of the corporation. The same rule states that in case of a nuisance or harassment suit, the court shall forthwith dismiss the case.


Must the corporation be made a party to the case?


Yes.


The Court said it is important that the corporation be made a party. The corporation is an indispensable party because it is the corporation's cause of action that is being litigated, and the judgment must bind the corporation.


The complaint must also state that the stockholder is suing on a derivative cause of action on behalf of the corporation.


What happened in Villamor v. Umale?


A corporation held an option to lease a property. Its board of directors passed a resolution waiving the corporation's rights under the option in favor of a law firm, for no consideration. The property was then subleased for a monthly rental of P4,500,000.00 plus goodwill of P18,000,000.00. The checks for the rent and goodwill were not turned over to the corporation.


A stockholder, who was also a director, wrote the other directors and asked that the checks or their value be delivered to the corporation. When they did not act, he filed an intra-corporate case and asked for a receiver. The Regional Trial Court denied the receiver. The Court of Appeals called the case a derivative suit, placed the corporation under receivership and created an interim management committee.


The Supreme Court set aside the Court of Appeals ruling. It found that the case was not a derivative suit because:


  • The stockholder did not show that his letter to the directors was all the remedy available under the articles, by-laws, laws or rules.


  • He did not allege that appraisal rights were not available for the acts complained of.


  • He did not implead the corporation, and did not allege that he was suing on its behalf.


  • He described the acts as harmful to his own interest as a stockholder.


The Court also ruled that the wrongs he described were wrongs to the corporation. So he had no cause of action that was personal to him.


How is a derivative suit different from an individual suit and a class suit?


The Court explained the three kinds of stockholder suits:


  • An individual suit is filed when the cause of action belongs to the stockholder personally. The Court's examples are denial of the right of inspection and denial of dividends to a stockholder. See the guide on the stockholder's right to inspect corporate books.


  • A class or representative suit is filed when the cause of action belongs to a group of stockholders, such as when the rights violated belong to preferred stockholders.


  • A derivative suit is filed when the cause of action belongs to the corporation.


Where the act complained of is a wrong to the corporation itself, the cause of action belongs to the corporation and not to the individual stockholder.


What is the appraisal right, and why does it matter?


The appraisal right is the right of a dissenting stockholder to demand payment of the fair value of his shares in the instances the law names. Villamor was decided under the old Corporation Code. The appraisal right is now in Section 80 of the Revised Corporation Code.


It matters because the third requisite asks the stockholder to show that no appraisal right is available for the act complained of. In Villamor, the failure to allege this was one reason the case was not treated as a derivative suit.


Can the court appoint a receiver or management committee in the case?


Only in the cases the rules allow. The Court said that receivers and management committees are appointed when there is imminent danger of both (1) dissipation, loss, wastage or destruction of assets or other properties, and (2) paralysis of business operations that may be prejudicial to the minority stockholders, the parties or the general public. The applicant must show both.


The Court also ruled that the Regional Trial Court, and not the Court of Appeals, has the power to make the appointment. Claims against directors are discussed in the guide on the duties and liabilities of corporate directors and in the post on conflict of interest rules for directors and officers.


Frequently asked questions


Who is the real party in interest in a derivative suit?


The corporation. The stockholder who files the case is only a nominal party.


Is a demand letter to the board enough before filing?


Not always. In Villamor, the stockholder wrote the directors, but he did not show that this was all the remedy available under the articles, by-laws, laws or rules.


Can a stockholder recover for himself what was taken from the corporation?


No.


A wrong to the corporation gives the cause of action to the corporation, not to the individual stockholder.


Which court hears a derivative suit?


The Regional Trial Court has original and exclusive jurisdiction over intra-corporate controversies, and the cases are tried by judges designated by the Supreme Court.


Sources




Need help with SEC or corporate compliance?


We handle SEC registration and reportorial filings, corporate governance, contracts and transactions for Philippine corporations and foreign investors. See our corporate services.



You can also email info@aureadalaw.com or call (02) 8812-9990.


Related guides



This article is general information as of its publication date, not legal advice, and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. For advice on your situation, consult a lawyer.

Comments


bottom of page